Babycarestudio Logo
a sleeping baby with a pacifier

Silicone vs. Rubber Pacifier: Which is Best for Your Baby?


Pacifiers have long been a staple in a parent’s arsenal when it comes to soothing a fussy baby.

They provide comfort, promote self-soothing, and can help reduce the risk of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS).

When choosing a pacifier for your little one, you’ll likely come across two popular materials: silicone and rubber.

Understanding the differences between them can help you make an informed choice for your baby’s comfort and safety.

Understanding Silicone Pacifiers

Silicone pacifiers are a modern innovation that has gained popularity in recent years. They are made from silicone rubber, a synthetic material that is both durable and hygienic.

Here are some key characteristics of silicone pacifiers:

1. Durability and Longevity

One of the primary advantages of silicone pacifiers is their durability. They can withstand repeated sterilization and maintain their shape and integrity over time. Silicone is less likely to break or degrade compared to rubber pacifiers, making it a cost-effective choice in the long run.

2. Easy to Clean

Silicone pacifiers are easy to clean and sterilize. They can be boiled, run through a dishwasher, or soaked in sterilization solutions without losing their shape or becoming damaged. This ease of cleaning is essential for maintaining your baby’s oral hygiene.

3. Hygienic Material

Silicone is a non-porous material, which means it doesn’t harbor bacteria or odors. This quality makes silicone pacifiers a more hygienic choice compared to rubber, as they are less likely to trap germs that could be harmful to your baby’s health.

4. Softer Texture

Silicone pacifiers tend to have a softer texture compared to rubber pacifiers. Many babies find silicone pacifiers more comfortable to suck on, which can be especially soothing for teething infants.

5. Allergen-Free

Silicone is hypoallergenic and does not contain latex or any known allergens. This makes silicone pacifiers an excellent choice for babies with latex allergies or sensitivities.

Learn more: 10 Best Non Toxic Pacifiers Of 2023

Exploring Rubber Pacifiers

Rubber pacifiers, also known as latex pacifiers, have been a traditional choice for generations. They are made from natural rubber latex, which is derived from the sap of rubber trees.

Here are some key characteristics of rubber pacifiers:

1. Natural Material

Rubber pacifiers are made from natural rubber latex, which is a biodegradable and sustainable material. Some parents prefer natural materials for their baby products.

2. Softer Texture

Similar to silicone, rubber pacifiers also have a soft texture. Many babies find them comfortable to suck on, and they can provide a soothing experience.

3. Natural Taste

Some babies may prefer the slight taste of natural rubber, which can make them more inclined to accept a rubber pacifier.

4. Eco-Friendly Option

For environmentally conscious parents, rubber pacifiers offer the advantage of being biodegradable. When disposed of properly, they have a lower environmental impact compared to silicone.

Choosing Between Silicone and Rubber Pacifiers:

When making your choice between silicone and rubber pacifiers, consider the following factors:

1. Baby’s Allergies:

If your baby has latex allergies, it’s crucial to opt for a silicone pacifier to avoid any allergic reactions.

2. Texture Preference:

Some babies may prefer the gentle, breast-like texture of rubber pacifiers, while others may feel more comfortable with silicone.

3. Durability:

If you’re looking for a pacifier that can endure extensive use, silicone pacifiers are a better choice in terms of longevity.

4. Cost:

Rubber pacifiers are generally more affordable, which can be a significant factor for many parents.


In the silicone vs. rubber pacifier debate, there is no one-size-fits-all answer.

Both types have their advantages, and your baby’s comfort should be the ultimate deciding factor.

Consider factors such as allergies, durability, and environmental concerns when making your choice.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Can I use both silicone and rubber pacifiers for my baby?

Yes, you can switch between the two types as long as your baby is comfortable with both.

How often should I replace pacifiers?

Both silicone and rubber pacifiers should be replaced every 2-3 months or sooner if they show signs of wear and tear.

How often should I clean my baby’s pacifier?

It’s advisable to clean the pacifier daily to maintain hygiene. Follow the manufacturer’s cleaning instructions for the specific pacifier.

Share this post

Sara Abdalla

Sara Abdalla

Sarah holds a Bachelor's degree in Child Development and her work has been featured in reputable parenting magazines, online forums, and advisory boards.

But Sarah doesn't just stop at research and expertise. As a mother of two herself, Sarah has amassed a wealth of experiences about what truly works for babies and what falls short of expectations.